Plan G (Medigap) vs Plan C (Medicare Advantage)

Choosing between Medicare Plan G and Medicare Advantage can feel confusing, especially when comparing premiums, coverage, and out-of-pocket costs. This guide breaks down both options side-by-side so you can make an informed choice that fits your health and budget needs.

TopicMedigap Plan G$0-Premium Medicare Advantage (Part C)
What it isA Medicare Supplement that works with Original Medicare (Parts A & B) to pay most leftover costs.A private plan that replaces Original Medicare for billing; it must cover all A & B services, often bundles Part D and extras. Medicare
Typical monthly plan premiumNational data show ~$164/mo on average (varies by age, zip, tobacco, rating method; roughly ~$140–$236 for many 65-yr nonsmokers). KFFMany plans are $0 plan premium (you still pay your Part B premium). Average MA premium in 2025 ≈ $17/mo, but $0 is common. National Council on Aging+1
Part B premiumYou still pay Part B.You still pay Part B (some MA plans partially offset it, but plan premium can be $0). Medicare
How A & B costs are coveredPlan G pays: Part A coinsurance & hospital costs; Part A deductible; Part B coinsurance/copays; first 3 pints of blood; SNF coinsurance; hospice coinsurance; foreign travel emergency (80% up to limits). It does NOT pay the Part B deductible. After you meet the Part B deductible, most A/B costs are covered close to 100%. Medicare+1MA plan sets its own copays/coinsurance for A & B services (e.g., fixed copay for PCP/specialist, copays per test or hospital day). You pay these until you hit the plan’s in-network maximum out-of-pocket (MOOP). Medicare
Out-of-pocket protectionNo MOOP in Original Medicare, but Plan G sharply limits your exposure (after the small Part B deductible, covered A/B costs are typically paid). There’s also a High-Deductible G option (lower premium, higher annual deductible). Centers for Medicare & Medicaid ServicesMA plans must have a MOOP. In 2025 the cap can’t exceed $9,350 (in-network) or $14,000 (combined in/out) for Part A/B services. Part D drug costs have a separate cap structure. KFF
Doctors & hospitalsAny provider nationwide who takes Medicare (no network). Great for travelers/snowbirds or those with multiple specialists.Network-based (HMO/PPO); out-of-network may cost more or be disallowed (HMO). Plans can require prior authorization for many services. Medicare+1
Drugs (Part D)Not included. Add a separate Part D plan.Often includes Part D. (Formulary, tiers, and pharmacies vary.) Medicare
Dental/vision/hearing & extrasGenerally not included (you can buy stand-alone).Often included as supplemental benefits (vary by plan and area). Medicare
Referrals / prior authNo referrals, no prior auth (you follow Medicare rules).Often required for high-cost services/procedures; varies by plan. Commonwealth Fund
When it shinesYou want the broadest access and predictable medical costs; you see specialists frequently; you travel; you prefer to avoid utilization hurdles.You value lower premiums and bundled extras (dental/vision/hearing/fitness) and are comfortable staying in-network and managing copays & authorizations.

In short:

  • Medicare Plan G offers predictable costs and nationwide provider access, ideal if you want fewer restrictions and don’t mind paying a monthly premium.
  • Medicare Advantage ($0-premium plans) trades flexibility for convenience — combining medical, drug, and extra benefits under one plan but with network and prior-authorization rules.

The right choice depends on your health needs, travel habits, and how much you value doctor choice versus bundled extras.

Example:

  • A 65-year-old non-smoker in North Carolina pays around $165/month for a Plan G policy.
  • A local Medicare Advantage HMO costs $0/month, but doctor visits are $10–$40 and hospital stays can reach $300 per day up to the plan’s out-of-pocket maximum.


🧾 Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

1. What’s the main difference between Medicare Plan G and a $0-premium Medicare Advantage plan?

Medicare Plan G works with Original Medicare to cover most out-of-pocket costs after you meet the Part B deductible. A $0-premium Medicare Advantage plan replaces Original Medicare with a private insurer that sets its own copays, networks, and often includes drug, dental, or vision coverage.


2. Does Plan G cover the Medicare Part B deductible?

No. Plan G does not pay the Part B deductible. Once you pay that small annual amount yourself, Plan G typically covers nearly all remaining Part A and B approved costs.


3. Do I still pay the Part B premium with either option?

Yes. No matter which plan you choose, you continue paying your monthly Part B premium to Medicare. Some Advantage plans offer a small “give-back,” but that depends on the plan and your zip code.


4. Which has lower monthly costs: Plan G or a $0-premium Advantage plan?

Many Medicare Advantage plans cost $0 per month (not counting your Part B premium). Plan G usually costs around $150 – $200 per month, but it greatly reduces out-of-pocket expenses when you need care. Advantage plans can cost more later in copays and hospital bills if you use a lot of services.


5. Can I see any doctor with Plan G or Medicare Advantage?

Plan G lets you see any doctor or hospital nationwide that accepts Medicare. Medicare Advantage plans use networks — usually HMOs or PPOs — which may limit your choices or charge more if you go out of network.


6. Do these options include prescription drug coverage?

Plan G doesn’t include drug coverage, so you’d need to buy a separate Part D plan. Most Medicare Advantage plans include Part D, but drug lists, copays, and pharmacy networks vary by plan.


7. Do Medicare Advantage plans require prior authorization?

Yes, many do. Advantage plans can require pre-approval for certain tests, surgeries, or specialist visits. Plan G follows Original Medicare rules and doesn’t require prior authorization for covered services.


8. What is a MOOP and how does it compare to Plan G?

MOOP means “Maximum Out-of-Pocket.” Medicare Advantage plans must set a yearly cap — up to $9,350 in 2025 for in-network care. After that, the plan pays 100%. Original Medicare has no MOOP, but Plan G limits your costs to the small Part B deductible plus your premium.


9. Can I switch between Plan G and Medicare Advantage?

Yes, but timing matters. You can switch during certain enrollment periods. Moving from Advantage to Plan G may require health underwriting unless you qualify for guaranteed issue rights in your state.


10. Which option is better for frequent travelers or snowbirds?

Plan G is generally better for travelers because you can see any Medicare provider nationwide and even get limited foreign-travel emergency coverage. Medicare Advantage plans are region-based and may not cover routine care outside your service area.



Written by Robert Simm
Licensed Health Insurance Broker — Generation Health
Robert Simm specializes in Medicare, Marketplace, Medicaid and supplemental insurance solutions. For help comparing your options, visit GenerationHealth.me.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *